Why NPS (Net Promoter Score) does not work

Published on — Written by Wonderflow

why nps doesnt work - wonderflow

Among all the metrics that companies use to measure their performance, one that has got much attention in the last ten years is for sure the NPS, or net promoter score

The NPS measures the willingness of customers to recommend your product or service to others. It is a score on a scale from 1 to 10, where customers evaluate themselves. Based on the given answers, customers are classified into three categories.

Detractors, who gave a score from 1 to 6, are basically people that are not satisfied with your product, and are far away from recommending it.

Passives, who gave a score from 6 to 8, are people that are ok with your product but are not big fans either.

Promoters, who gave a score from 9 to 10, are so excited about the experience with your product that would recommend it to others, acting as your ambassadors.

The Net promoter score is then calculated by subtracting the detractors from the promoters.

It sounds like an interesting indicator, right? In fact, many of the largest companies in the world use it extensively. For some others, the NPS is even part of the strategic goals. So how come we say the NPS does not work?

#1 – Not real

First of all, by asking customers if they would recommend your product, you are asking them to imagine something that they might do in the future, and not describe something that already happened. It is proven that by doing this, you are adding a lot of bias to the results, which become unreliable

#2 – Complexity

Secondly, we shouldn’t forget that the NPS is still a survey, and usually, there are other questions together with the main one. By adding other questions to the NPS we are adding a layer of complexity for the respondents, and we add even more bias to the answers, which are not free anymore but guided

#3 – Answers

Third, it is hard to learn something from it. Even if we decide to take the risk and trust the NPS, we would hardly extract any insights, unless we add an open text question. In that case, the challenge becomes reading all the free text answers. If you don’t do that, the NPS would product only quantitative information, but won’t tell you “why” someone is happy or not with your product

It’s hard to accept that today’s most iconic marketing metric it is unreliable and obviously overvalued! However, you can still run experiments to verify the quality of the results. For example, you can change the main question from “will you recommend us” to “have you recommended us?” In this way, we would talk about the past, and It would become much easier for customers to answer.

If you still want to run the NPS, at least make sure it contains only two questions, where the first is the score from 1 to 10, and the second is a free text, where customers are free to write whatever they want

If you don’t want to use the NPS anymore, you should consider alternative sources of feedback, such as reviews, social or interviews! Remember that voluntarily generated feedback is by far the most insightful, and it’s also the cheapest to get!

Learn more about why you should stop asking questions to your customers here.

About Wonderflow

Wonderflow empowers businesses with quick and impactful decision-making because it helps automate and deliver in-depth consumer and competitor insights. All within one place, results are simplified for professionals across any high-UGC organization, and department to access, understand, and share easily. Compared to hiring more analysts, Wonderflow’s AI eliminates the need for human-led setup and analysis, resulting in thousands of structured and unstructured reviews analyzed within a matter of weeks and with up to 50% or more accurate data. The system sources relevant private and public consumer feedback from over 200 channels, including emails, forums, call center logs, chat rooms, social media, and e-commerce. What’s most unique is that its AI is the first ever to help recommend personalized business actions and predict the impact of those actions on key outcomes. Wonderflow is leveraged by high-grade customers like Philips, DHL, Beko, Lavazza, Colgate-Palmolive, GSK, Delonghi, and more.

Start making winning decisions based on customer feedback todayGet a free demo

Other articles you might like:

Lucia Manetti

Interview · Dec 23, 2021

Employee Spotlight: Lucia Manetti, Marketing Specialist

Part of our recent success and growth has been largely due to our people. In particular, if we had to pick another hard-working teammate for this month alone, let’s meet Lucia Manetti, our Marketing Specialist. Lucia has held nearly six years of experience in the tech industry.  Funny enough, however, she graduated with a degree in the History of Art and one in Concept Art for Videogames. Afterward, she got her master’s in Digital Marketing….

wonderflow image

Interview · Nov 25, 2021

Employee Spotlight: Brenno Pellegrini, Product Designer

Part of our recent achievements and growth has been mainly due to the people. So, we’re excited to feature another hard-working team member in our Employee Spotlight of the month. Meet Brenno Pellegrini, our Product Designer and the first one to join the Design Team. Born and raised in Trento, a small city lost between the mountains in northern Italy, Brenno studied chemistry during high school at ITT, also in Trento. However, he loathed it…


Customer experience · Nov 18, 2021

10 Tips on How to Get a Good Net Promoter Score (NPS)

In a past post, we helped define the net promoter score (NPS), including calculating NPS and its differences against the customer satisfaction score (CSAT). Now, we expand on the topic in this article by focusing specifically on how to improve NPS.  However, the NPS is no better than the CSAT or other customer experience (CX) metrics. It also does not always work, depending on how your company uses it and an organization’s business model, preferences,…